Summary
- Hershey stock has underperformed other food peers.
- This is logical, as Hershey didn't enjoy the same quarantine sales boost as rivals.
- However, the company's long-term outlook is fine, and at the present dividend yield, it's quite attractive.
- Looking for a helping hand in the market? Members of Ian's Insider Corner get exclusive ideas and guidance to navigate any climate. Get started today »
While the stock market keeps powering higher and higher in general, not all stocks are going up equally. In fact, many of the names that benefited from the eat-at-home trend during the virus have sold back off in recent weeks. Hershey (HSY) is right up there. Shares have dipped 13% since their April rebound level and are off more than 20% from the 52-week highs.
Data by YChartsAs the chart shows, Hershey initially outperformed the broader market and stuck closer to its peers in the Consumer Staples ETF (XLP).
Since May, however, the S&P caught up to consumer staples, meanwhile Hershey diverged from both to the downside. As a result, Hershey is down 20% while both its sector and the broader market are only down 10%. This isn't a huge performance gap, but if you're looking to go shopping for high-quality stocks that you can buy and hold for decades, even a 10% or 20% price savings can make a huge difference on results.
Why Is Hershey Underperforming Lately?
Sometimes, it's complicated trying to parse out differing performance among peer companies within a sector. In this case, however, the explanation is simple: Hershey didn't benefit much from the stay-at-home demand surge. The company said as much in a business update last month:
"We continue to see declines in our food service, owned retail and world travel retail businesses as well as certain parts of our International businesses as a result of known shelter-in-place and other restrictions. We have also experienced a decrease in retail foot traffic and volatility in consumer shopping and consumption behavior across several areas of our portfolio, which has negatively impacted sales of our portable and on-the-go consumption products."
Chocolate is often an impulse buy. Consider where it is located at grocery store - right next to the check-out aisles, hoping you'll grab one on the way out. Chocolate is a high-margin business, and as such, grocers put it in prime position to drive marginal sales to weary shoppers.

