Hershey: Back In Play

Eight weeks ago, Hershey (NYSE:HSY) shareholders got a jolt when it was suddenly announced that Mondelez (NASDAQ:MDLZ) was pursuing a bid for the Hershey Company. While the specifics weren't immediately known, the price immediately jumped to nearly $120 per share from the mid $90s. Shareholders immediately received three years worth of capital gains in one day, and when the speculative dust settled, it was revealed that Hershey had received a bid of part cash and part stock at $107 per share. However, the price did not come back down to Earth as there was speculation that a better price was forthcoming, and the stock continued to trade well over $100. Today, however, the wait was ended as Mondelez retracted their bid. This is a welcome announcement, as the uncertainty had left both long term shareholders and new prospective shareholders in a bind. Unnecessary uncertainty is the enemy of prudent investment, so with this speculation now ended, is Hershey worth looking at?

The Acquirer

For long term shareholders, if the deal had been completed and Mondelez had acquired Hershey, the company would have been in worse hands than it is currently. Their CEO publicly made a few poor decisions when they ran Kraft, and even earned a public rebuke from Buffett back in 2010. Further, their decision on how exactly to split Kraft up in 2012 seems to have been poorly thought out, and without a rescue from Buffett of the new Kraft Company, there would have been little to show for either firm from the split. The firm seems to need to stay busy, as the management talent to deliver solid returns does not seem to be there. Mondelez consistently shows poor return on equity, as it has been above 10% only once in the past four years since the spinoff, and has been below 8% twice. Hershey has performed much better on this metric, and has delivered ROE consistently over 50%. Therefore, a more profitable firm would have been absorbed by the relatively weaker firm in this instance. From this perspective, there are multiple other firms I would rather have acquired Hershey when looking at management talent.

READ FULL ARTICLE HERE